I think there's a lot of misconception about 'genetic diseases'. If you have an extra 21st chromosome you have Down's Syndrome – 100% of the time. But most diseases that are now being labeled as “genetic” ignore that our environment shapes our genetic expression. Genes are not all static, but responding to the environment they are in. What you eat, breathe, etc causes many genes to be expressed, or not, so just having a gene doesn't mean you have or are going to get a disease.
Trying to push genetic determinism is good business for those who want to sell 'cures' (e.g., drugs & surgery) but I think it's one sided science. I would hate to see dogs with that gene removed from the gene pool since most of the time genes serve multiple purposes and via diversity of expression can also have helpful attributes. The fact that 80% of the dogs may have this - with relatively few expressing it - should give us pause and perhaps cause more research onto what causes this to be activated.
I'm getting a little off topic here, but with humans genes activation is influenced by diet, exercise and stress. Dr. David Kessler, M.D. ( FDA commissioner during Bush and Clinton days) has a
new book out about overeating. Specifically, about the interaction of fat, salt, and sugar to release dopamine and how they have highly addictive effects – possibly more than cocaine. Studies have shown that when you eat sugar not only do your genes turn off controls designed to protect you from heart disease and diabetes, but the impact lasts for two weeks. I know people who are working on a treatment for obesity, based on a genetic cause, totally ignoring the role of eating a diet high in fat, salt & sugar has on genetic expression. There’s money to be made. I won’t go on and on about it, but if you’re interested there’s more
here.
I guess my point is just to say that having a gene doesn’t necessarily mean you will get a disease (except in something like Downs) and most genes serve multiple purposes so eliminating them from the pool will most likely have unintended consequences. Better to look at how to raise healthy dogs using proper nutrition, exercise, etc.